Skip to Content
Back to news
Published by

Clare Stainthorp

17 November 2026, 5:13 UTC Share

UPEN workshop offers new insights into evaluating Areas of Research Interest

A UPEN report earlier this year showed the impact of a lack of evaluation frameworks for ARIs. Last month, we brought together ARI leads and practitioners from across the UK to discuss different approaches to evaluation and test a Theory of Change framework.

Evaluating the impact of developing, publishing, and mobilising Areas of Research Interest (ARIs) has been a longstanding challenge for the ARI practitioner community. UPEN’s 2026 report Regional Areas of Research Interest: Challenges, opportunities, and next steps highlighted a lack of systematic evaluation for ARIs, leading to challenges demonstrating their value. Creating robust and flexible evaluation frameworks that capture both process change and substantive outcomes is a priority if we want to effectively embed ARIs into the academic-policy engagement ecosystem.

UPEN’s second ARI Project peer learning workshop, held in York on 22 October 2026, brought together 40 ARI leads and practitioners from across the UK for a vibrant day of discussions on approaches to evaluation in complex environments and to stress-test a baseline Theory of Change.

The diversity of ARIs

We kicked the day off with conversation starters, which quickly emphasised the diversity of contexts within which ARIs are being deployed. Chloe Corbyn (Senedd), Juliet Jopson (Leeds City Council and West Yorkshire Combined Authority), Elizabeth Lomas (Department of Digital, Culture, Media and Sport), Ryan Owens (West Midlands Combined Authority), and Rosie Sadler (Sport England) shared their reflections on approaches taken to monitoring and evaluation. These presentations established an underlying theme for the day: how to adapt and flex an ARI process to meet the needs and available capacity of a policy organisation.

Nicky Buckley, UPEN Institutional Lead (Areas of Research Interest), reflected: “The learning workshop was really helpful because of the candid insights that ARI practitioners and those coordinating ARI responses were able to share. There were great examples of practice from ARI practitioners, from creating evidence champions in policy teams, to quarterly prioritisation of evidence needs by analytical teams. The overview of different evaluation methods that we considered opened our eyes to a range of possibilities.”

Practical insights

Participants collectively discussed what works, where challenges exist, and practical solutions. We learned about organisations who are instituting frameworks for their interactions with universities alongside ARIs. These new frameworks can lead to other forms of engagement, including commissioning research and new knowledge exchange partnerships.

What was clear from the discussions was the critical need for a suite of resources to support the development, delivery, mobilisation and evaluation of ARIs, including an adaptable Theory of Change model.

We also learned about systems for knowledge management which help to effectively triage responses, which don’t need to be complex to be effective. For example, organisations are increasingly using a simple online ARI response form to gather information from those responding to an ARI, providing key data and insights for monitoring engagement along with helping teams pass approaches on to relevant colleagues promptly.

Adaptable approaches

A core part of the day involved testing the structure and content of a baseline Theory of Change framework, which organisations can use as a foundation and adapt to their specific contexts. A key insight from this activity was the need to be pragmatic about the potential impact of an ARI process as a mechanism that connects two complex systems: universities and evidence producers; and policy development.

Max French and Melissa Hawins (Northumbria University) continued this conversation in their session, shining light on how people’s roles and experiences fundamentally shape what they consider to be success for an ARI. Subjectivity around the value of an ARI adds complexity to creating one and has important implications for evaluation. They advocated for evaluation approaches that acknowledge ambiguity and uncertainty, are inclusive and participatory, and encourage continuous learning as a core purpose.

This was followed by a discussion about adapting a monitoring and evaluation framework for different policy contexts. There was general support for the idea of a decision tree or matrix to help policy organisations decide upon a proportionate evaluation approach.

What does this mean for UPEN’s ARI Project going forwards?

Rob Davies, UPEN Institutional Lead (Areas of Research Interest), concludes: “What was clear from the discussions was the critical need for a suite of resources to support the development, delivery, mobilisation and evaluation of ARIs, including an adaptable Theory of Change model. Responding to these calls for action, UPEN’s ARI Project Team will now lead on the development of a new Resource Navigator, informed by peer feedback and testing of draft resources and tools in ‘live’ environments through our ARI Policy Fellows.”

If you’re an ARI Practitioner who’s interested in the development of these practical resources, you can get involved by joining our Community of Practice. To see the resources we’ve already published, as well as a list of all UK ARIs, check out UPEN’s ARI page.

Back to news

Sign up to our newsletter

* indicates required